06 Mar 2015

Comment: CML’s Response to the Proposal of Rent Controls

Comment: CML’s Response to the Proposal of Rent Controls


Samantha Morrice, Senior Solicitor comments on the Rent Control proposal.

The Scottish Government is currently consulting on new tenancy rules for the private rental sector in Scotland, and the Council of Mortgage Lenders (CML) have recently shared their response to the proposals. In general the CML has said they will be welcoming many of the changes, however they do have several reservations regarding the proposals in relation to rent controls and the effect they will have on buy to let lending.

Current Status

Currently the rental market sees wide variations from place to place in Scotland. Aberdeen and Edinburgh for example, much like the sales market in these cities, have seen above average increases in the last year. Most of this is due to lack of supply in these cities, the CML has therefore encouraged the Scottish Government to address the supply of homes in areas where this is a problem, and not try to enforce market rent controls. 

The CML’s reasoning behind these concerns are twofold, firstly they feel that lenders may see the rent controls as an increased risk, and they will need to consider that the rental income will cover the mortgage costs and the impact that the rent controls may have. Secondly, they are concerned that Landlords themselves may also be discouraged by the proposals. They may not be able to afford to continue to invest in the property, or seek to charge a higher rent at the outset to offset the risk, which in turn may have an impact on the quality and the availability of privately rented properties. Therefore the concern is that it may leave tenants in a worse position.

Those in favour of rent controls are of course to make rental accommodation more affordable and could potentially allow rents to rise in line with inflation.

Additional Concerns

The CML are also concerned about the removal of the no-fault grounds for repossession, the CML believes “that Landlords need to have confidence in their ability to end a tenancy when they need to do so, otherwise this may discourage future investment in the sector”.

Furthermore they object to the provision to exclude the current ability of landlords and tenants to roll over tenancies on a monthly basis. The main objection is due to the fact that the existing arrangements provide flexibility for both, and allow Landlords to return to their properties if need be. If this is no longer an option in the system then the number of abandonments may also increase.


Whether or not the CML’s response will lead to the Scottish Government amending their proposals remains to be seen. The Scottish Government is due to report on the end of its consultation by the end of March 2015. Seek expert advice on the many regulations facing Landlords.

Samantha Morrice, Senior Solicitor


Please correct the errors below before submitting your request:

Get in touch

Our dedicated client contact team prefer to receive enquiries through our contact form. We'll endeavour to get back to you within 24 hours or during the course of the next working day.

Tick this box if you wish to receive news and offers from Aberdein Considine. By doing, you indicate your consent to receiving targeted email marketing messages from us. On each occasion that we contact you in the future, you will be given the option to opt-out from receiving such messages. You may also email marketing@acandco.com at any time to opt-out.

The personal information that you provide to us in this form will only ever be used by Aberdein Considine (as the Data Controller) for the following specifically defined purposes:

  • email you content that you have requested from us
  • with your consent, occasionally email you with targeted information regarding our service offerings
  • continually honour any opt-out request you submit in the future
  • comply with any of our legal and/or regulatory obligations